As the 6 Nations draws itself to an end, i find myself wondering what we have learnt about the competing teams over the last couple of months….
1) Owen Farrell ain’t bad is he?
When the EPS squad was announced, there was mass groans of ‘he’s only there cos his dads the coach’, well, he’s proved people wrong. His size was one of the ‘issues’ people had with him, but originally at centre, and latterly at 10, he’s been impressive in his defence. Look at the hit he made at the end of the France game on Harinordoquy. Fantastic.
2) Stuart Lancaster wasn’t out of his depth after all!
Not much to expand on, but despite some turgid, kick and chase performances, its the first time in several years that England have won all 3 away games, IF England beat Ireland tomorrow, we will be left to rue Courtney Lawes sloppy ball handling against Wales…. a Grand Slam potentially given away! So can we take supporting a side that wins ugly?
3) Wales are the real deal.
After some impressive displays during the world cup, some people wondered if the Welsh could keep developing, and yes, they have, North, Cuthbert and Halfpenny could be one of the best back 3′s in the game before long. Size, strength, speed and most importantly, youth is on their side. The forwards are beginning to find there stride, though the strength in depth of the pack is somewhat questionable.
Pre tournament, i had Wales winning, but not doing a slam, a’la England last year, but Gat’s boys have really stepped up and with England and Wales seemingly headed towards very young teams, 2015 and 2019 could be very interesting world cups for the home nations!
4) Scotland.
Well. What can you say about the Scots? So much promise, again, gone down the pan as they again face a wooden spoon shoot out with Italy. Patience must be wearing thin with Andy Robinson. I think Scotland have something like 1 win in their previous 12 or 13 games, its not good enough!
The seemingly early retirement of Dan Parks forced Scotland to add more youth to the ranks, Ruaridh Jackson needs to step his game up, as does Greg Laidlaw, but add them to guys like Stuart Hogg, Lee Jones, Duncan Weir etc and the emergence of Richie Gray as a genuine talent and David Denton and Ross Rennies very promising (and aliterative) back row partnership and also several players to return from injury and maybe they are a year away from being competitive.
5) France.contradictoire
France constantly amaze and disappoint. Phillippe Saint Andre was supposed to be the glue that added steel to the flair, and it hasn’t worked, They are blessed with some amazing players, but never seem to show up for an entire tournament. Fofana with 4 tries in 4 games looks like one to watch, but key players in Servat and Bonnaire are retiring after the 6 nations and they will need to replace them ASAP
6) Italy. la stessa vecchia Italia
I know Italy have improved. BUT. They are not competitive, they have tried several combinations in most positions over the years, but its not clicking. The Bergamasco’s and Parrisse are not getting any younger and as soon as these guys go, its hard to see where the future lies for Italian Rugby. Is it time for Georgia or Russia to have a chance? Personally i’d like to see the bottom side in the 6N, which seems to annually be Scotland or Italy’s private battle, should play off with the winner of the European Championship (or Tier 2 6 nations) with the winner playing in the 6 nations, and the losers having to fight to get back in.
7) Ireland
No BO’D, PO’C injured, Sexton never looking comfortable, RO’G sat on the bench…. it didn’t look good. but Donncha Ryan, Sean O’Brien, Stephen Ferris et al have been frequently great performers and add in to that the phenomenal Tommy Bowe, Keith Earls and Rob Kearney and also Sexton proving people wrong by holding off the challenge of Ronan O’Gara and its actually been a moderately good 6 nations for Ireland in everything but the results. A loss to Wales and a draw with France won’t be enjoyable, sneaking past spirited Scotland and destroying feckless Italy leaves Ireland in position to jump into 2nd place if they can beat England at Twickenham, with it also being St Patricks day, that game could well be an epic encounter!
8) Overview
Its been an odd tournament. All 6 sides are trying to rebuild, whether on the pitch, or in the coaching department (and in Englands case, both!) and mostly they all seem to be pushing for young guys to emerge and make the positions their own, its truly been a proving ground.
The player of the tournament shortlist is utterly ridiculous, for the record.
Malzieu, Maestri and Harinodoquy of France, Denton and Rennie from Scotland, Phillips, Lydiate, Warburton and Cuthbert of Wales, Parisse of Italy and Sexton and Ryan from Ireland.
Basically, the men of the match from the first 4 rounds. I don’t understand how that can find a player of the tournament! For example, Harinordoquy got MOM v England, but i think everyone outside of France felt Tom Croft far more deserving, but the award was chosen by French TV. Thats a really unfair system.
So. With a round to go, i will give my personal 6 players of the tournament, 1 from each side.
England :- Owen Farrell. (honorable mentions, Croft for consistency and Tuilagi for his gamebreaking ability)
France :- Wesley Fofana (Honorable mention to Harinordoquy, he’s a beast.)
Italy :- Sergio Parisse. (Honorable mention to Mirco Bergamasco)
Ireland :- Tommy Bowe (Honourable mention to Ferris, who is a silent assassin!)
Scotland :- Richie Gray (Honourable mention to Ross Rennie)
Wales :- Leigh Halfpenny (Honourable mentions to…. well, just about everyone else!)